





Welcome to the first post in the “Under Investigation” series. Everyone worries about government investigations. They can be criminal or civil, and companies in regulated businesses like aviation, banking, telecommunications, insurance, mining, healthcare, logistics, securities and transportation need to be extra vigilant. How well do you know the tools investigators use? That’s what this series is about. It provides a general overview of the tools used by government agencies and is not specific to EPA agents or construction site searches. The tools vary depending on the agency and the case. Part I discusses the main tools.
The government may issue subpoenas for your bank accounts, business or personal. The subpoena can also demand the production of documents from your company or grand jury testimony of an individual. By producing the documents by the due date, you can often avoid testimony.
A CID is a civil investigative demand, which is a request for documents and other information in civil cases. CIDs are used to investigate potential violations of antitrust, banking-related consumer protection and health care fraud statutes. A CID can demand documents, sworn written interrogatory answers, and sometimes testimony before a federal prosecutor.
The IRS may issue a summons to turn over records or to testify. Sometimes the IRS sends a summons requiring the taxpayer to answer questions about certain tax years before an IRS-CI special agent. It’s a sure sign the investigation is criminal and should be taken seriously.
The Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) issues subpoenas for securities investigations. They can subpoena documents and testimony under oath. A formal order of investigation that authorizes enforcement attorneys to issue such subpoenas precedes the subpoena.
When your company gets investigated by the government, it’s common for the government to interview the company’s employees and ex-employees, as well as the company’s competitors. The government agents are trained, educated and usually know the industry. Even if you’re innocent, politely decline to talk to the government until you have a lawyer. They’ll keep asking you questions until you slip up. You never know what you might say that will be used against you. Talk to the agents without counsel, and you are handing the prosecutors a gift-wrapped indictment. Remember, “Nothing to Hide” is not a defense.
In some cases, the government may place an informant, whistleblower or cooperator inside the business. They may be wearing an audio or video recording device. The government may try to obtain incriminating evidence by using the informant, whistle-blower or cooperating witness to make controlled calls, emails or texts.
Sometimes the informant can get carried away. They can play secret agent and do their own investigation. They can copy the contents of the company server without permission. The informant’s conduct may be beyond the bounds of what is lawful.
Besides informants, data mining is frequently used to root out health care fraud. Many private health plans have specialized investigative units (SIUs) which data mine health care claims to identify fraud.
Government agents may execute a search warrant at your business. Agents will enter the premises and, depending on the search warrant, seize records, computers, cell phones, data within the scope of the warrant. In the regulated industries, it is becoming more and more common. A search warrant is very stressful. A search warrant is not an interrogation. It is a search only. Your employees do not have to speak with agents during the search. The agents may try to interview your employees. Never agree to an interview during a search warrant without first meeting with a lawyer.
So, you get the idea, be careful when and if government comes calling. The government has seemingly unlimited resources. If you work in a regulated field and you’re subject to an investigation, get in touch with an experienced investigations attorney.